DOJ asks appeals court to intervene for California mail-in ballot lawsuit
Table of Contents
Justice Department Seeks Emergency Action Over California Mail Ballots
Provpnadvice.com – The Department of Justice has asked the Ninth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals to step into its dispute with California over more than 20,000 mail-in ballots that the Trump administration says may have been cast by people who are not U.S. citizens.
The federal government wants the ballots withheld from California’s midterm election tally while the citizenship status of the voters connected to them is reviewed. Its appellate request arrived before U.S. District Judge David Carter issued a decision on the Justice Department’s earlier motion for emergency relief.
Carter has scheduled a hearing on whether the state should be prevented from counting the ballots until officials verify the citizenship of the roughly 20,000 voters at issue. The case has placed federal enforcement officials and California election administrators in a direct conflict over how voter eligibility concerns should be handled during an active election process.
Federal government presses for ballots to be set aside
The Justice Department filed its lawsuit against California last week after giving state election officials 48 hours to separate ballots tied to the listed voters for review by the Department of Homeland Security. Federal officials contend that California should not include the disputed ballots in its count until eligibility questions are resolved.
In its legal complaint, the department said the state was asked to assess citizenship independently when possible. Where that could not be done, the federal government sought to have any ballot from a person on the list held apart pending confirmation.
If California was unable to independently confirm the citizenship of people on that list, the Federal Government asked that California set aside ballots received from them until the person’s citizenship was confirmed.
The department’s request focuses on a list of more than 20,000 people it identifies as likely noncitizen registrants. The administration has argued that allowing ballots connected to those names to proceed through the normal count could affect the integrity of the election.
On Monday, the Justice Department announced charges against 28 people accused of registering or voting illegally despite not being U.S. citizens. It said most of those individuals voted using what it called “illegal and fraudulently obtained ballots.”
Deputy Attorney General Trent McCotter said every suspected noncitizen charged appeared on the larger list shared with California election officials the previous week. The 28 criminal cases form a small portion of the wider group referenced in the federal lawsuit, but the administration has cited them as support for seeking an immediate court order.
Newsom says request conflicts with election law
California Gov. Gavin Newsom, a Democrat, has sharply rejected the lawsuit and the demand to set aside the ballots. He has characterized the federal action as an effort to force state officials to depart from the procedures that govern California elections.
California’s elections are NOT Donald Trump’s to control. We will ensure EVERY California voter can participate in a free and fair election.
Newsom said the administration was asking California election officials to violate federal law. He has also accused President Trump of using the Justice Department in an attempt to suppress California voters in advance of the midterm elections.
In a written response, Newsom called the request unprecedented and warned that it should concern Americans beyond California. He pointed to the longstanding principle that states administer their own election systems, including the practical work of processing and counting ballots.
We will continue to carry out free and fair elections in the Golden State — and call out this authoritarian as he tries every play in the dictator’s playbook.
The governor described the administration’s efforts as “sad, desperate” attempts to restrict participation. His response frames the dispute not only as a disagreement about a particular group of ballots, but also as a broader test of state authority over election administration.
Potential consequences for election officials
The Justice Department and Trump have warned that California officials could face criminal charges if all of the disputed ballots are included in the midterm count. That warning has raised the stakes of the legal battle, which now involves both the emergency request before Carter and the appeal to the Ninth Circuit.
Trump said last week that election officials who were convicted would face lengthy prison terms.
will all go to jail for a long period of time!!!
The immediate legal question is narrower than the broader political dispute: whether California must pause the handling of ballots associated with the 20,000 names while citizenship is checked. A temporary order would not by itself determine the final validity of every ballot, but it could change how quickly the state completes its count and how disputed ballots are treated during that process.
California, meanwhile, maintains that its election officials must follow established voting procedures and protect the ability of eligible voters to participate. The state’s position is that federal pressure cannot override the rules governing its elections simply because the administration has raised allegations involving a large list of registrants.
The case now puts the Ninth Circuit and the district court at the center of a high-profile confrontation over voter eligibility, federal enforcement and state control of elections. Their decisions will determine whether the ballots are counted under California’s ordinary process or held aside while the federal government’s citizenship concerns are examined.
Related Reading
Frequently Asked Questions
What is DOJ asks appeals court to intervene?
DOJ asks appeals court to intervene is the main topic of this guide. The article explains the context, practical details, and next steps readers should understand.
Why does DOJ asks appeals court to intervene matter?
DOJ asks appeals court to intervene matters because readers are looking for a useful answer, not just a short summary. Good content should match search intent and help them decide what to do next.
